How do I access an instance's name?

I want to get the name of a classe's instance at runtime. Is this possible?
ie.

Code:

---

class MyClass
{
....
public:
    void getInstanceName();
}

void getInstanceName()
{
    cout << "Hi, I am " << ?????????? << endl;
}

int main()
{
MyClass John;
john.getInstanceName();
}

---

Quote:

---

I want to get the name of a classe's instance at runtime. Is this possible?

---

Sure. Define a method in the class that returns the class name.

you mean you want it to return "John" -- the answer is no.

Well, actually there is a way you can do that. Add a string object to the class to hold the instance name then add a constrol that takes the instance name as a parameter. But of course there is no guarentee that getInstanceName() will return the right name if you pass the wrong name to the ctor (garbage in, garbage out principal).

Code:

---

class MyClass
{
public:
  MyClass(const char* instanceName) {m_instance = instance_name;}
  std::string getInstanceName() {return m_instance;}
private:
  std::string m_instance;
}

...
...
int main()
{
  MyClass John("John");
}

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ancient Dragon

Well, actually there is a way you can do that. Add a string object ....

---

Yes, though this is surely cheating, isn't it? The whole idea is to avoid hand feeding a string to the constructor. "John-John" just looks ugly to me! Thanks anyway.

Why do you need that? Other than for some advanced topics I can't think of a reason.

The name of a variable is seen by the compiler, and is not accessible at run time.

If you want an object to be aware of it's name, YOU need to implement functionality so it is, with an approach like that suggested by Ancient Dragon.

Of course, this approach doesn't stop an object declared as

Code:

---

  MyClass John("Bill");

---

reporting that it's name is Bill.

If you want to do away with the typing, use a macro;

Code:

---

#define CreateMyClass(x)  MyClass x(#x)

int main()
{
    CreateMyClass(John);
}

---

As long as the programmer always uses the CreateMyClass macro, an object named John will always report its name as John. The catch with this approach is that there is no way to force the programmer to use the macro. And the fact that a macro has other effects which are not always desirable, because it works by pasting of text before the compiler sees the code.