I give it a 9. It wasn't perfect, but it was pretty faithful to Tolkein's original vision I felt.
How about you?
10 (excellent)
9 (a few minor faults, but otherwise perfect)
8 (not quite brilliant, but worthy of being a classic)
7 (pretty average)
6 (just below average)
5 (passable)
4 (lacking)
3 (urgh...)
2 (a waste of time)
1 (complete rubbish)
I give it a 9. It wasn't perfect, but it was pretty faithful to Tolkein's original vision I felt.
How about you?
