Let me throw out a couple more nuggets for ye' to mentally chew on:

To what extent can PETA and others determine Vick's career? Assuming they do not wish him to return to NFL football, then what is he allowed to do to earn a living? The man has to support for his family some how... is he allowed to work for McDonalds? Will PETA (and others) condemn McDonalds for supporting animal abuse?

If a U.S. President lies under oath, yet is allowed to continue his Presidency... can an NFL player return to the field if he lies to his boss? (not under oath.. but still a substantial character flaw)