Professional JavaScript for Web Developers, 2nd ed.

neandrake · 05-14-2009, 08:26 PM

Professional JavaScript for Web Developers, 2nd ed. by Nicholas Zakas is a great book for getting further in depth with the language. A great reference which covers a lot of cross-browser differences (and solutions). There's tons of information in this book, and it has helped me a great deal at work. I mostly use this for understanding others' JavaScript and also as a reference. Touches on advanced topics, but doesn't go too in depth on advanced design and usage, but covers plenty good information which experienced programmers can apply. The cover price is $50 - I was lucky to have this covered as a work expense. If I had to pay out of pocket I would say it's worth $30-$40. As someone who had touched on JS several years back, and was mostly afraid of it, I now feel a lot more comfortable developing and maintaining it. I rate it 4.5/5 stars (lack of more advanced design and usage), but well worth it for Beginner to (slightly) Advanced.

Covers multiple methods (with pros and cons) of OO designs, different types of Event mechanisms, the DOM, Xml, Ajax, etc. Even includes information on efficiency and speed.

[edit] I've read reviews of the 1st edition of this book, and many seem to be disappointed with it. Please remember that this review is for the 2nd edition.

MK27 · 05-15-2009, 08:15 PM

Hey silly me, I just noticed you reviewed this book separately from that other one. Unless you are some kind of web wizard who snuck this onto the board in the wrong order to screw with my mind.

I have some negative criticism of this book in neandrake's review of "Professional Ajax".

It is not a bad book, tho. I actually feel guilty; it was good enough that I managed to learn javascript DOM and OOP methods in about a week and use them to write the client side of a dynamic database*. So Mr. Zakas must have done a pretty good job -- I'm just a nasty ingrate. It is very in depth and understandable, and his personality is imperceivable, which is a nice style. No hype or nonsense. None. By "doesn't go too in depth on advanced design and usage" I would guess neandrake means there are no big example projects that tie everything together, because I am pretty sure everything is there.

*the only thing I've done with that is create an address book...but it works. The "dynamic database" was my idea, it's not in the book.

neandrake · 05-16-2009, 09:44 AM

Just to clarify, what I meant by not going too in depth is that yes, there wasn't any much coverage of large-scale projects. My concern in that area is about how well the content of the book scales. The content clearly useful in most all situations, but what about in larger applications (gmail, facebook, etc.) -- do they use the same techniques, patterns, etc.? The reason I made the comment is actually because of a video I saw online of a Google Talk where they had some JavaScript professional talk about making library in JS, and it touched on some topics that I wasn't familiar with, after going through most of this book.

05-14-2009, 08:26 PM	#1
neandrake 30 Helens Agree Join Date: Jan 2002 Posts: 607	Professional JavaScript for Web Developers, 2nd ed. Professional JavaScript for Web Developers, 2nd ed. by Nicholas Zakas is a great book for getting further in depth with the language. A great reference which covers a lot of cross-browser differences (and solutions). There's tons of information in this book, and it has helped me a great deal at work. I mostly use this for understanding others' JavaScript and also as a reference. Touches on advanced topics, but doesn't go too in depth on advanced design and usage, but covers plenty good information which experienced programmers can apply. The cover price is $50 - I was lucky to have this covered as a work expense. If I had to pay out of pocket I would say it's worth $30-$40. As someone who had touched on JS several years back, and was mostly afraid of it, I now feel a lot more comfortable developing and maintaining it. I rate it 4.5/5 stars (lack of more advanced design and usage), but well worth it for Beginner to (slightly) Advanced. Covers multiple methods (with pros and cons) of OO designs, different types of Event mechanisms, the DOM, Xml, Ajax, etc. Even includes information on efficiency and speed. [edit] I've read reviews of the 1st edition of this book, and many seem to be disappointed with it. Please remember that this review is for the 2nd edition. Attached Images __________________ AIM: Neandrake EMAIL: nta0 @ yahoo . com Operating System: Windows XP SP2 Compiler: GCC IDE: Notepad++ Don't give up your freedom to think - www.cognitiveliberty.org Last edited by neandrake; 05-14-2009 at 08:45 PM.
neandrake is offline

05-15-2009, 08:15 PM	#2
MK27 subminimalist Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: NYC Posts: 3,944	Hey silly me, I just noticed you reviewed this book separately from that other one. Unless you are some kind of web wizard who snuck this onto the board in the wrong order to screw with my mind. I have some negative criticism of this book in neandrake's review of "Professional Ajax". It is not a bad book, tho. I actually feel guilty; it was good enough that I managed to learn javascript DOM and OOP methods in about a week and use them to write the client side of a dynamic database. So Mr. Zakas must have done a pretty good job -- I'm just a nasty ingrate. It is very in depth and understandable, and his personality is imperceivable, which is a nice style. No hype or nonsense. None. By "doesn't go too in depth on advanced design and usage" I would guess neandrake means there are no big example projects that tie everything together, because I am pretty sure everything is there. the only thing I've done with that is create an address book...but it works. The "dynamic database" was my idea, it's not in the book. __________________ Accuracy and integrity mean nothing if you don't make it past the censors...PYTHAGORAS Last edited by MK27; 05-15-2009 at 10:45 PM.
MK27 is offline

05-16-2009, 09:44 AM	#3
neandrake 30 Helens Agree Join Date: Jan 2002 Posts: 607	Just to clarify, what I meant by not going too in depth is that yes, there wasn't any much coverage of large-scale projects. My concern in that area is about how well the content of the book scales. The content clearly useful in most all situations, but what about in larger applications (gmail, facebook, etc.) -- do they use the same techniques, patterns, etc.? The reason I made the comment is actually because of a video I saw online of a Google Talk where they had some JavaScript professional talk about making library in JS, and it touched on some topics that I wasn't familiar with, after going through most of this book. __________________ AIM: Neandrake EMAIL: nta0 @ yahoo . com Operating System: Windows XP SP2 Compiler: GCC IDE: Notepad++ Don't give up your freedom to think - www.cognitiveliberty.org Last edited by neandrake; 05-16-2009 at 04:23 PM.
neandrake is offline

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Professional Ajax 2nd edition	neandrake	Programming Book and Product Reviews	5	06-08-2009 08:46 AM
Ex. 2-4 KnR (2nd ed.) loop && array handling	olbas	C Programming	2	03-23-2004 11:07 PM
A poll for professional developers (non professionals can also answer)	incognito	A Brief History of Cprogramming.com	19	03-25-2003 03:04 PM
A poll to professional developers	incognito	A Brief History of Cprogramming.com	0	03-21-2003 07:45 PM
Developers, Developers, Developers, Developers	Betazep	A Brief History of Cprogramming.com	15	10-27-2001 09:15 PM