Accessing a protected member declared in parent class

Hi,

I have a base class character, a child class pacman, and a file called manager.cpp which contains main and serves to manage the characters in the game while the game is in progress.

In Character.h I have declared desiredDirection and its mutators and accessors as follows:

Code:

---

protected:
        void setDirection(int newDirection);
        const int getDirection() const;
        void setDesired(int newDirection); //set desired direction
        const int getDesired() const;
                      ...

private:
                      ...
        int direction; //current direction
        int desiredDirection;
                      ...

---

In manager.cpp I have declared pacman to be a global variable as follows (I know global variables are naughty but I haven't thought of the best way to manage the characters yet so its temporary):

Code:

---

#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdarg.h>
#include <stdio.h>
#include <math.h>
#include <string> //might be able to remove later - here for debugging

#include "Map.h"
#include "Pacman.h"
#include "Ghost.h"

using namespace std;

Pacman * pacman;

---

in the same file (manager.cpp), I need to access pacman's desiredDirection and I do it as follows:

Code:

---

void Timer(int extra)
{
        if (pacman->getDesired() == 4)
                pacman->move();
        else
        {
                pacman->move();
                pacman->setDesired(pacman->move(pacman->getDesired()));
        }
        glutTimerFunc(30,Timer,0);
}

---

before I had this working by having desiredDirection as a global variable in Manager.cpp but I'm trying to avoid using global variables. When I compile my program I get:

manager.cpp(43) : error C2248: 'Character::getDesired' : cannot access protected member declared in class 'Character'
character.h(38) : see declaration of 'Character::getDesired'
character.h(15) : see declaration of 'Character'

I'm guessing the only way I can use the getters and setters is if I used them within pacman's implementation file? So, if I need access in manager.cpp, what would be the best way to do it?

Your getters and setters shouldn't be protected, but public. (If they are protected, then no one can access them, which means they are extremely pointless.)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tabstop

Your getters and setters shouldn't be protected, but public. (If they are protected, then no one can access them, which means they are extremely pointless.)

---

Well, technically, the class itself, and any that inherits from it can access protected members (be it functions or variables). This make protected in itself fairly pointless, since you can either not inherit the class anyways - in which case they may as well be private, or you if you want to access the member, you just inherit the class into your own derived class and have your merry way with whatever member it is you want to "play" with.

But for the usage described above, the setter/getter members need to be made public to make them work.

[And of course, ANY of the members are really accessible to anyone who can see the class variable (or guess where it is), since there is always the possibility of casting it into a pointer that you can access the memory of the object with - but that's sort of cheating :)]

--
Mats

thanks I got so lost in playing with inheritance within the pacman class that I lost sight of the fact that it's totally normal to have mutators and accessors be public haha. thanks for bringing me back to earth :P